Mahindra has been trying to get its share in the SUV market in India with it's Scorpio. However, the performance of the car did not meet the expectations of the Indian car lovers. Comfort of driving was not up to the mark. The MUV from Toyota (Innova) was often compared with Scorpio even though they are not really in the same class. And Scorpio was not even close to driving comfort of Toyota Innova. Another comparable car is the luxury SUV - Toyota Fortuner, which was considered a far superior car compared to Scorpio and Innova.
Mahindra Scorpio could not even give any close competition to Toyota. This made Mahindra in an embarrassing position. However, the arrival of Mahindra XUV 500 could change the equations. Mahindra XUV 500 can give a very tight competition to Toyota Innova and Fortuner.
Who are the potential customers of Mahindra XUV 500?
There are many potential customers like me, who want:
1. Comfort of Innova, but some thing more in terms of features, elegance, luxury etc
2. Power of Scorpio, but not the uncomfortable driving
3. Elegance/luxury of Fortuner, but not too high price
And Mahindra XUV 500 meets all of the above 3 criteria for me. It offers comfortable driving (I haven't done a test drive yet, but the specification of the car says it can give a comfortable drive), luxury comparable with Fortuner, affordable price (about 35% less price than Fortuner).
I have been looking at Innova and Fortuner for a while and could not decide which one to pick. I wanted something better than Innova but Fortuner was too high on the price. My first impression of Mahindra XUV 500 is, it is THE CAR FOR ME.
Compare Mahindra XUV 500 to Toyota Fortuner
Toyota Fortuner is a luxury class SUV and should not be really compared to a much lower priced Mahindra XUV 500. However, since Mahindra does not have an equivalent class car and Toyota does not have a lower segment SUV, let us take a closer look at them and compare the features.
Mahindra XUV is a much lower priced SUV, compared to Toyota Innova. The ex showroom purchase of Mahindra XUV 500 in New Delhi is 10,80,000. The Fortuner would cost you about 18 lakhs in the same city, which is about 65% higher price than XUV. This gives a big advantage for XUV 500. Those who want a good performing global car without spending a lot, Mahindra XUV is a great canidate. If you can afford the premium cost to own a Fortuner, go for it.
Engine and Power
Toyota Fortuner boasts of a 4 Cylinder, 3 Liter TDCI D-4D Engine which offers lot of power and performance on off road driving. Maximum power is 126kW @ 3600 rpm. Maximum torque is 343 Nm @ 1400-3400 rpm.
Mahindra XUV is powered by mHawk 2.2 litre diesel engine. Other Engine specifications:
Displacement: 2179cc, mhawk140
Engine Type: Diesel
Maximum Power: 140 Bhp @ 3750 rpm
Maximum Torque: 330 Nm @ 1600 rpm
Here is the detailed, feature by feature comparison of Mahindra XUV 500 and Toyota Fortuner:
|Feature||Mahindra XUV 500||Toyota Fortuner|
|Engine Type|| 2.2 Liter mhawk140||3.0 Liter TDCI D-4D|
|Transmission||6 speed manual||5-speed manual|
|Max Power||140 Bhp @ 3750 rpm||126 kW @ 3600 rpm|
|Max Torque|| 330 Nm @ 1600 rpm ||343 Nm @ 1400-3400 rpm|
|Variants||- Mahindra XUV500 W6 4x2|
- Mahindra XUV500 W8 4x2
- Mahindra XUV500 W8 4x4
|Toyota Fortuner 4x4|
|Front end Treatment||General||Projector-type headlamp|
|Price||New Delhi: Rs 10,80,000* - 12,88,000|
Chennai: Rs 10,96,000* - 13,07,000
Bangalore: Rs 10,91,000* - 13,02,000
Mumbai: Rs 11,28,600* - 13,45,960
|New Delhi: Rs 20,45,030*|
Chennai: Rs 20,76,383*
Bangalore: Rs 20,62,302*
Mumbai: Rs 20,36,815*
Kolkota: Rs 20,75,608
|Mileage||10 - 12 kms per liter||8 - 10 kms per liter|
|Fuel tank capacity||70 liters||80 liters|
|A/C & Climate control||Yes||Yes|
|Central remote locking||Yes||Yes|
|Seating capacity||7 seater||7 seater SUV|
|Dimension||Length is 4,585mm|
Width of 1,890mm
Height measuring 1,785mm
Wheelbase of 2,700mm
|Length is 4,695mm|
Width is 1,845mm
Height of this SUV is 1,850mm
Wheelbase is 2,750mm
|Suspension||Front : McPhesron type with anti roll bar|
Rear : Multi-Link type with anti-roll bar
Brakes : All disc brakes
|Front : Double wishbone coil springs|
Rear : 4-link with coil springs
Brakes : Ventilated disc brakes
|Entertainment||CD/DVD player, IPOD can be connected||CD/DVD player, IPOD can be connected|
Which car to buy - XUV 500 or Toyota Fortuner?
In my case, I am really confused. Since I work from home and already have another car, I am not in a hurry to make a decision. I would wait and see how Mahindra XUV 500 perform in the coming few months and listen to feedback from people who really used it for a while.
In a nutshell, this is what I found so far:
1. Fortuner is a luxury car and have the feel-proud advantage compared to XUV 500.
2. Fortuner is from Toyota which offers great service in India.
3. Toyota cars have proven reliability and credibility, but not all Mahindra cars can claim the same.
4. Fortuner is longer and taller than XUV, but the XUV is wider than Fortuner. Which one you prefer?
5. XUV gives a better mileage (+2km).
6. Mahindra XUV 500 has lot of advanced and sophisticated systems, but not all Mahindra service centres are equipped to handle this kind of sophisticated cars.
If both the cars come at the same price, Toyota Fortuner is undoubtedly the winner. But the price of Fortuner is about Rs 10 lakhs more than XUV 500. Do you think it is worth paying such a premium for Fortuner when XUV 500 is pretty close on comfort and luxury?
If you want to buy cars online, check out AutoJunction.in.
|Guest Author: carazoocarz 30 Nov 2011|
|Thanks for the good article that has good Comparision for Mahindra XUV 500 and Toyota Fortuner along with Price difference and Engine and Power. Hope to see potential customers of Mahindra XUV 500.|